(Jen Arnall-Culliford in her Puffin Apple hat design)
As part of our Cross-Country collaboration, Jen and I thought it would be interesting to interview each other about our different approaches to producing our different designs. (You can read Jen’s interview with me over on her blog today.) Jen is a sharp, focused and highly professional tech editor. In this capacity, she has worked with me on many projects, including Colours of Shetland. But she’s also an accomplished designer, though for some bizarre reason she doesn’t really think of herself as such. This is something that I think needs to change, because Jen designs beautiful, well-thought out patterns, and has, I think, a genuine feel for the structure and behaviour of textured stitches. She has a real knack of bringing a classic design to life with a well-thought out, well-placed motif, such as that which you can see on her Puffin Apple hat above, or the Bruton Hoody (below) that she designed for Cross-Country Knitting. Jen, you are a talented designer, and must keep on designing! (Anyway, you can’t stop now as there are already plans afoot for Cross-Country Knitting Volume Two! ho ho.)
I should also mention that, as well as being available via Ravelry as an ebook, Cross Country Knitting, Volume One is now also available as a beautifully-produced 20 page booklet, which you can order in print from Magcloud.
So here’s Jen’s interview.
Where did you start, Jen, when planning this design?
When we hatched the Cross-Country Knitting plan, I had pretty much hung up my designer hat, and decided to concentrate on editing. I am constantly faced with the temptation of casting on the projects that I edit, and I’m lucky enough to edit many of my favourite designers, so I was generally feeling as if I didn’t have much to add to the vast number of stunning patterns that are already out there. And then something like this came along, and tempted me out of “retirement”. The opportunity of publishing an eBook with you was too much to resist, you temptress! There are also situations where I want an item, and I just can’t find the right pattern out there. I design for pragmatic reasons, rather than because I have a constant supply of inspiration just welling up within me. In many ways, I see myself as a reluctant designer, with enormously encouraging friends within the industry.
Anyway, when I do decide to design, different designs take me in different ways! This time I knew that I wanted to design something for Jim. I knew that it couldn’t be too fussy, but I wanted some knitting interest as well.
Inspiration came from a number of places…
* Jim wears lots of zipped cardigans and hoodies.
* I had a vague memory of a T-shirt he once loved that had a trio of stripes down the left side.
* Maria Erlbacher’s Twisted-Stitch Knitting is one of my favourite stitch pattern collections.
* Editing Nick Atkinson patterns for The Knitter had shown me some clever ways of knitting strips within a piece without having to break off yarns.
*Over a period of days, these different strands came together in my head to create a hoody with interesting construction and a twisted stitch panel on one side.
How did you go about choosing yarn for the design? How much did you swatch?
Ever since I used Excelana 4ply for my Snawheid, I have wanted to use Excelana (from Susan Crawford and John Arbon Textiles) for a garment. It was SO pleasurable to knit with. I’ve had some in my stash for ages, and cracked open a ball for swatching. I tried both the DK and the 4ply weights in good-sized swatches (this is unusual for me – I’m usually a lax-swatcher who will get away with a micro-swatch whenever possible – naughty Jen!). The yarn is perfect for texture work. It’s a lovely balance of great stitch definition, springy woolliness and softness. The Persian Grey shade was also spot on for Jim’s clothes palette, but not too dark to hide the cable panel. The hoody would also be gorgeous in the Cornflower Blue shade, or Ruby Red perhaps!
(Jen’s Snawheid, knit in Excelana)
Is knitting your design an essential part of the process for you?
Again, it very much depends on the design. Some designs evolve during the knitting (Puffin Apple with its many rips and reknits stands out here!), and others are so well-formed in my head that I can start with writing the pattern straight away. I’m lucky enough to work very closely with Kim Hobley, who does a lot of sample knitting for me. She often helps me to create a design in a reasonable timescale that would otherwise have been impossible. For Bruton, I was working on a smaller-scale version (which is currently in hibernation). I needed to knit the technique so that I could explain the construction clearly in the written instructions, but in this case Kim knitted the full-size sample. We see each other regularly, so she can let me know quickly if anything isn’t going to plan, and I can check on progress too. As a technical editor I’m very used to imagining through the steps of a project and ensuring that the instructions are clear, without actually knitting it myself. I’m also happy to make calculations from the swatch and write up the whole thing from that point.
In the end I have chosen the DK weight for Bruton, as I knew I would be more likely to knit a man’s hoody in DK rather than 4ply, and the swatch has a satisfying weight and drape to it.
(Jen’s swatches for the Bruton Hoody)
What are your aims when you write up the pattern?
I go with the same principle I used when I wrote up my Chemistry PhD thesis! Someone should be able to easily follow my instructions and get the exact same results. They shouldn’t be left wondering whether I did it one way or another. I aim for as consistent a pattern writing style as possible, with a balance between including lots of detail, but not over-complicating things. You can’t account for everyone’s pattern preferences, but I aim for a set of instructions where the information is presented as logically as possible. You and I have fairly similar pattern writing styles, so we were able to make a few minor changes on each side and ended up with something which works for both of us. I lost the cast off/bind off battle (it wasn’t really a battle!), but in return I was able to capitalise your abbreviations. Compromise being an essential part of teamwork.
(Kate says: ho ho, next time everything will be lowercase)
Were there any challenges that were specific to designing a man’s garment?
Getting the balance of designing something that Jim would wear, but that knitters would not be bored to tears by was tricky! I’m happy with the finished garment, and Jim has been wearing it non-stop for the last 12 months, so I’m guessing he is happy with the outcome as well. I’ve been holding myself back from stealing it for my wardrobe too!
I love the hat you’re wearing, too!
Nice going. I have never had a problem with one of Kate’s patterns so I would expect it would be the same for you, especially since you are collaborating. Good clear interview also! thanks.
Congratulations on a great looking design! I have been following you on the quiet for a while and love the way you write, explain and recommend. Well done!
I found this interview very interesting! I’m so glad there are designers out there who write their patterns with absolute clarity in mind. It’s greatly appreciated.
I enjoyed both of your interviews very much! It is so interesting to see how a design is born. Thank you!
Thank you for the description of how you arrrived at your design. So many different strands make for a richer design. (Which is why you should keep designing. Yes, there are a lot of patterns out there, but we need thoughtful patterns from thoughtful designers.)
So happy to see these amazing new designs for men. Finally, I can stop searching for the next sweater my husband will actually wear!
i hope you two girls will some day write about the fatal attraction of knitting for academics and chicks with phds. there is one such a coven known to me here in albuquerque (a college town) of art historians of a very special kind — heiroglyphics experts (pre-columbian kinda mandates this). i know there is a strong kind of post-marxist labor connection, at least for dr. davies, and for the art history crones here, i think there’s a lot of a kind of archaeological interest in resuscitating vintage patterns and also the whole magic sculptural thing of creating a three dimensional garment out of the linear ball of yarn. (big medicine.)
kate, i am still trying to navigate the farther reaches of materialism as you introduced it to me via bill brown, and i think, as a bear of little brain who cannot knit a hoodie for a stuffed rabbit, which i really want to do, that this may be the cohesive thread. real deep dialectical, you know, materialism which resists the approaches of a simple country mystic like i.
please do write about it. you. felix. all of you. bluestocking stitchery 4eva.
The intersection of science brains and knitting yet again! Just proof that all those women from the past who knitted gansies and other amazing pieces of knitting architecture had a lot going on in their heads. And yes, the challenge with designing for men is exactly as Jen stated–to come up with something interesting to knit, but also very wearable. I’m lucky enough to have two men in my life (a husband and a son) who are willing victims of my efforts. Great interview. I’m so glad the two of you collaborated on this project.
Very interesting piece and an elegant hoody!
And who is the hunky young man?
Oh, I love this! It’s informative and so interesting to learn of another’s process! And, I must add, completely charming and delightful as well. Thank you so much!
How adorable is that…I have to admit that for a truly comfortable wear all day hug, I am tempted to “borrow” a sweater knit for my Hubby……this is a great design, as is Tom’s fair isle…..two to look forward to wearing myself :)